|
Sometimes
referred to as "astral projection" in esoteric
literature, out-of-body experience ("OBE"
or "OOBE") is a more neutral term to describe
the sensation of feeling as if consciousness,
or the self, is located somewhere other than
where the body is physically located.
Some psychologists tend to view OBEs as simply
a form of hallucination. For example, British
psychologist
Susan Blackmore refers to it as a
particular "cognitive map," an alternative
mental model, in which the mind acts as if it
were experiencing the world not from the usual
perspective -- that of the body -- but from
some other location. In line with this
interpretation, considerable work has been
undertaken to explore whether people having
OBEs have any particular psychological
characteristics that would account for such
hallucinatory experiences.
On the other hand, there are some scientific
experiments in which the person having the
out-of-body experience seems to actually
perceive distant events or targets, as if
their consciousness is truly located in that
distant location.
An intermediate position between the two
extreme interpretations - true relocalization
of the mind vs. mere hallucination - is that
the OBE is a particularly powerful altered
state of consciousness which both induces a
subjective impression of mind-body separation,
and greatly enhances the person's clairvoyant
psi capacities. Experiments such as Tart's
were not designed to distinguish between this
hypothesis and the «projection» idea, but
other studies have attempted to address this
distinction.
In the mid-1970s, Dr. Robert Morris and his
colleagues conducted an interesting experiment
with psi researcher Keith Harary as subject.
Like Miss Z, Harary - at the time a psychology
student - seemed able to voluntarily induce an
OBE. His kitten, enclosed in a cage and
constantly filmed, was to act as a biological
detector of Harary, who would attempt to
'project' his consciousness into the cage from
a distant room. Indeed, it was found that the
kitten's agitation - its movements in the cage
- was significantly reduced specifically at
the moments at which Harary had been
instructed to project his consciousness into
the cage. Over time, however, the kitten's
"baseline agitation" decreased, and its
reactions to Keith Harary seem to have
declined - perhaps as it became habituated to
the experimental conditions (i.e., being
locked in a cage!)
Of course, just as Tart's experiment could be
interpreted in terms of ESP, so too the early
results of this study could be interpreted in
terms of mundane psi: perhaps Harary simply
entered a mental state in which he exerted a
calming influence upon his cat, i.e., through
a form of bio-psychokinesis. A more stringent
test would be for the person having the OBE to
both report distant events, and to be
"detected" at the distant location.
The late Karlis Osis, of the American Society
for Psychical Research, sought to determine
whether a physical instrument could detect a
psychic's "astral body" at the time he was
attempting to view a hidden target through his
astral vision. Osis installed a strain gauge
(which detects extremely subtle physical
movements) in front of an optical device in
which a graphic "target" was concealed. The
setup was such that the image could only be
perceived face-on - from the place where the
strain-gauge was located; otherwise, from a
different angle, a viewer would only see
overlapping lines. The psychic Alex Tannous,
who was not told about the strain gauge, was
asked to attempt to project in front of the
optical apparatus, and describe what he saw.
Osis found that the strain gauge registered
significantly more movement in those trials in
which Tannous gave correct descriptions of the
target. The implication may be that some facet
of Tannous' mind was indeed "projecting" in
front of the optical apparatus.
It is still possible to entertain the idea
that in such experiments there is no true
"projection," but rather a combination of
successful ESP trials and unintentional PK
activity. The ideal experiment for astral
projection would probably necessitate not just
ESP tasks and mechanical or biological
detectors, but also several human observers
who could independently attest to the presence
of the subject's "astral body" at the moment
at which projection is being attempted.
In the meantime, as suggested by psi
researcher Carlos Alvarado, a primary
objective would be to pay much more attention
to the phenomenology of the OBE, as described
by those who actually have these experiences;
we may discover that terms like OBE or astral
projection cover a wide range of different
phenomena, and that no single explanation can
account for them all. |